Critical Diagnosis: Week of November 9-13, 2026 by Jeff Giles

If you were going to make a list of essential soap ingredients, you wouldn't get very far without adding a line item about stories that force characters into doing the wrong things for the right reasons. That, maybe more than anything else, has fueled classic soap stories for decades, working a narrative magic that's only amplified by the fact that viewers are bonded further to these characters because they see them five days a week.

I thought about this a lot while watching last week's General Hospital, because most of what's happening right now ignores everything I just said in favor of drama fueled by characters acting like complete scumbags for absolutely no good reason. I've complained a lot in this space about this writing regime's evident comfort with erasing history and contorting characters in order to get wherever they think the show needs to go, and that's exactly what's happening right now, pretty much everywhere you look across the canvas.

I think this is bad writing in a fundamental sense, but there's no denying that it can produce short-term dividends, which is basically why it's happened so often across the daytime spectrum in the post-O.J. era. The conventional wisdom now, at least as far as I can discern any, is that it's fine to do whatever you need to in order to goose the ratings. If it means breaking something, well, you can always retcon it away later. A lot of soap writing these days just comes down to characters telling the audience how they're supposed to feel about what they're seeing anyway, so what difference does it make, right?

What makes the current state of GH extra annoying is that we aren't even seeing short-term dividends. Splashy things are happening, but they aren't interesting enough to distract from the fact that a lot of them hinge on alleged protagonists acting like the worst people in the world and being utterly unable to justify it at all. 

Here's what I mean.

He Doesn't Want a Daughter. He Wants a Payday

From the beginning, the entire Phoebe storyline has felt like the work of writers who don't know what they're doing and don't particularly care. It started, lest we forget, with Chase and Brook Lynn stumbling across a woman named Delilah, who just so happened to be completely alone and fully in labor while they were out on a romantic stroll — just the first coincidence in an expanding array of them that has since grown to include Delilah's connection to Ethan Lovett and Jude Jacks.

Saddened by Delilah's death during childbirth, Chase and Brook Lynn resolved to foster Phoebe, and were thrilled to hear that her father was willing to sign over his parental rights and allow them to adopt her. Basically as soon as the ink was dry on the adoption papers, they decided to get a divorce — and as soon as the ink was dry on their divorce papers, they met Jude, who told them they'd been lied to, the adoption was bullshit, and he was actually Phoebe's father.

This is a classic soap situation, which is to say it's absolutely outlandish. There's nothing wrong with that as the foundation for a storyline. Once it's been established, though, the players need to be making decisions we can relate to. As I noted up top, a typical soap storyline involves characters doing bad/wrong/illegal things for understandable reasons; this storyline, at least so far, is atypical, because it hinges on some truly scummy behavior on the part of Brook Lynn and Chase.

Chase, admittedly, has been the better of the two, but that's only because Brook Lynn is acting so awfully that in comparison, it seems like no big deal for Chase to confront Jude at the freshly renovated Metro Court bar and basically tell him that he doesn't care whether or not he is really Phoebe's father. This is an utterly insane response for a police officer to have to a man claiming he's been kept from his infant daughter, but it's nowhere near as bad as what Brook Lynn is up to. 

Like Chase, Brook Lynn instantly decided to keep Jude away from Phoebe — but unlike Chase, Brook Lynn now knows, thanks to Ava, that Jude is probably telling the truth about Phoebe's parentage. This is obviously a horrible thing to learn once you've bonded with a baby and gone through all the steps to complete what you believed to be a lawful adoption, but that still pales in comparison to the pain felt by a parent who finds out their child has been put up for adoption without their consent. Any fictional character who isn't the most despicable kind of villain would have no choice but to feel for the father in this situation, and agree to find out whether their claims are based in reality.

Not Brook Lynn! After hearing from Ava that Ethan lied about being Phoebe's father, allegedly to protect her from her real one, Brook Lynn doubled down on her efforts to keep Phoebe — and she was roundly supported by everyone in her circle, including sweet, stupid Gio (although, to his credit, Gio did eventually point out that they'd both been burned by a fucked-up adoption, and asked her if maybe, just maybe, she was really the bad guy in this situation).

So what we have here, in essence, is a ludicrous storyline arising from the ashes of a marriage that was never interesting. A storyline that asks us to identify with the blatantly illegal and jaw-droppingly selfish actions of a character who's supposed to be one of the good guys, all predicated on supposedly damning information about another character who, while we barely know him, has conducted himself quite reasonably for a person in his situation. This is not, in other words, a good soap storyline.

The writers seem to understand this on some level, because last week, they finally got around to telling us why we're supposed to hate Jude. Are you ready for this? Are you ready for Jude's deep, dark secret? I hope you're sitting down, because here it is: He used to work for JJE, and in an attempt to prove himself to his uncle Jasper, he tried to bribe Australian officials in order to get around some mining laws. He was fired and cut off for this, but not completely: As Joss smugly told Jude when she ambushed him in his hotel room, she knew her father had set up a large trust fund for any children he might have. So this is Jude's unforgivable offense — his uncle set aside a pile of money for his kids, so ergo, the fact that he's trying to gain custody of his own child must mean he really only cares about money.

I feel like I have to be belaboring the obvious here, but I'm going to say it anyway: This is an abominably shitty storyline, one undermined by mistakes that absolutely did not need to be made. If we're supposed to hate Jude, then it was up to the writers to show us why, and if they couldn't be bothered to show us, then they sure as hell needed to do a better job of telling us. This crap about mining laws? Look, I admit that I was on a break from GH when Jax first darkened our door, but from what I recall, he joined the show as a corporate raider, which means that on his best day, he's five times the jackass that Jude ever would have been for trying to make JJE a quick buck.

What is the conflict we're supposed to be feeling here? How can anyone involved in this show believe the audience is rooting for Brook Lynn and Chase? Why is any of this even happening?

If there's a silver lining to be spotted, I'd say it's Wil Traval. The writers don't seem to know who or what Jude really is, and Traval seems to be leaning in to that confusion by playing him as a guy who might be a monster, or might just be a little rough around the edges. It might just be that Traval is as confused by the writing as I am, but either way, the result is a performance that keeps the viewer slightly off-balance and makes us wonder what Jude's really capable of. This isn't much, but it's the nicest thing I can say about a repellent waste of time and talent across the board.

Josslyn Started This. I'm Gonna Finish It

I'm not sure I've ever once rooted for Sonny, so putting him on a list of characters that are acting like indefensible scumbags is nothing new for me. That being said, he's currently being written as an even worse person than usual, which is really saying a lot.

From the beginning, his beef with Joss has been written like something that's only happening because the writers are determined for it to happen — and that got even worse last week, when he went off the deep end because she made the unforgivable mistake of saying true things about him in front of our new Avery. Never mind that Joss was only at Sonny's house to return the bug she found planted in Hudson's briefcase — she's supposed to know that when you're part of Sonny's extended family, your number one job is to ignore his decades of criminal activity.

Because GH has spent years desperately trying to make the audience see Sonny as a hero, this situation can't be treated with the complexity and nuance it deserves. Rather than treating this as a story about an ex-mobster's teenage daughter coming to terms with the truth about her father, and centering the action around Avery and her feelings, last week's episodes gave most of the oxygen to Sonny, who stomped around town bellowing about how nobody comes between him and his kids without payin' da price.

In theory, I don't think there's anything wrong with pitting Sonny and Joss against each other, but as I've said before, this really only works if there are real, intractable reasons for their conflict. We haven't been given any good reasons for Sonny to be so hellbent on retaining ownership of the piers that he'd be willing to feud with his former stepdaughter — and it's also insulting to the audience's intelligence that even though Sonny has gone legit, we're still seeing him run his operation in the same old way, barking orders about "keeping eyes" on people and making vague threats against his enemies.

A year or two ago, I wrote about how Sonny's real value at this point lies in the way he's wired into so many points on the canvas. He knows pretty much everyone in Port Charles and he's been through pretty much everything a soap character can go through, which would make him a great source of perspective and advice for anyone in town. What this dumb storyline makes abundantly obvious — again — is that Sonny no longer functions as a character who can drive this type of story. When you have to scrape and flail this badly to put him dangerously at odds with another character, it's a very clear sign that it's well past time to start putting your energy into using him in different ways. Watching him growl threats toward Joss is just painful, and painfully dull.

On the brighter side, I have nothing negative to say about the new Avery, who looks the part and did fine in her scenes with Sonny, Joss, and Ava. Unfortunately, her arrival was used mainly as an excuse to make Joss sniffle and whine all week about how she shouldn't have told Avery the truth about her father, but Sonny and Ava's war has made even less sense with her existing entirely offscreen for the last year-plus, so I'm heralding her arrival as a positive sign.

I Drew

Speaking of the painfully stupid Sonny vs. Ava storyline that has led Ava to forge a senseless alliance with Drew, let's move on to our final couple of unrepentant jerkoffs. For a long time now, I've felt like the writers have no idea what to do with Ava, but they know enough to know that Maura West will spin soap gold out of whatever bullshit they hand her, so they've made an unfortunate habit of tossing Ava into ridiculous situations and hoping for the best.

All of this business with Drew and Ava has been patently ridiculous. She never had any reason to throw in with him, and her willingness to hold her silence after Nina was carted off to WSB jail for a crime she didn't commit is offensive. But now that we're here, we might as well get some soapy twists and turns, and we got one last week after Drew — who was rightly freaked out about the prospect of Ava turning on him — met with Monet and came away with a plan to save both of them. That plan? A quickie Drew/Ava wedding that would (at least in the world of General Hospital) prevent either of them from having to testify against the other.

This is silliness, but it's the right kind of silliness, at least for a soap. The only good part of mashing Drew and Ava together is the fun of watching them bicker with each other, and if they end up turning their unholy alliance into a domestic partnership, it'll open up plenty of solid opportunities for entertaining arguments. But will they get married? That was thrown into doubt toward the end of Friday's episode, when Lucas — at the wedding as Ava's witness — pointed out that it would be pretty shitty for Drew and Ava to get married without their daughters present. Meanwhile, Joe and Molly were booking it to the courthouse to put a stop to the ceremony, following a search of Drew's office that turned up a Post-It giving away Drew's matrimonial plans.

I tend to think the wedding will happen, if only because it's hard to envision a better way of tying Drew and Ava more tightly together while also keeping them from being arrested for their very obvious role in Brennan's body being buried in the woods. On the other hand, that marriage won't really save Ava from Dante, who — thanks to a little nudge-nudge, wink-wink from Elizabeth — now knows she went to GH to be seen for a bite from the same species of tick that was found on Brennan's body.

Either way, I don't really think any of this is worth the damage it'll do to a couple of characters who could both be put to far better use. Drew has settled into his role as a villain at this point, and every show needs creeps like him, but I'd rather see him scheming and conniving more intelligently; right now, he's just sloppy, and I think we'd get better stories out of him if he were written as someone who's smart enough to be formidable. Ava, meanwhile, is way too cunning to get herself mixed up with a loser like Drew. She deserves better than this, and so do we.

Rayon Stilts

There isn't a whole lot to write about where Trina's concerned right now, and I suspect she'll be more of a focus in the next week or two, but it probably bears mentioning that Simon booked her and Gio as the opening act for a band called (sigh) Rayon Stilts at the Port Charles Arena. Gio, worried about Trina being exposed to her stalker, pushed back, at which point Simon threatened to drop them, and Trina insisted that no stalker would stop her from pursuing her dream, etc. etc. etc.

Trina still seems wholeheartedly convinced that Heather is the one doing the stalking — and Portia shares that conviction so steadfastly that she basically threatened Heather in front of Dante. The rest of us aren't so sure. Heather definitely seems sincere in her insistence that she's back in Port Charles to try and make amends for her past crimes, and Dante has correctly pointed out that Heather's way too out in the open to stalk anybody successfully. It's Soap 101 for a character like Heather to be dangled as a red herring for this type of storyline, so I'll be very surprised if she turns out to be the one behind this.

I'll be just as surprised if I end up caring who is behind it. While Joss gets the run of the canvas, engaging in super-spy intrigue and steering her father's multi-billion-dollar company, Trina has been sidelined with a deeply lame pairing, saddled with a stakes-free storyline, and shunted off to a part of the canvas where nothing cool ever happens. Tabyana Ali and Braedyn Bruner need to be rescued from this dark place. Everyone else who's been sucked into it can stay where they are.

That'll do it for the big stuff this week! Now for your bullets:

  • Britt had more sex with Jude, and now she's happy again
  • Through a scheme too convoluted and nonsensical to bother describing, Serena convinced Jason to give her and Lucy creative control of Deception
  • The writers remembered that Sonny speaks Spanish
  • Felicia accused Lucy of wanting to sell Maxie's house
  • After being confronted by Emma, Heather threatened to wash her mouth out with soap
  • Ava flashed a steak knife at Heather
  • Alexis told Molly — and later gave a statement to Dante — about Brennan blackmailing Drew
  • Turner told Anna about her relationship with Sonny, and Anna did not throw up

Comments